Wednesday, May 5, 2010

And So, the Adjuncting Year Draws to a Close... Not with a Bang but a Whimper.

The three people who read this blog already know that I had a rough academic year, so I won't belabor the point. What surprises me at this juncture is the regret (mixed, of course, with profound relief) that I feel at having decided not to sign on again for next September.

The idea of turning down work, particularly during this economic, er, clustercuss, makes me very uncomfortable. On the other hand, the icey claws of doom I felt digging into my shoulders every time I drove through the college's front gate were somewhat worse than uncomfortable. And it's not as if anyone was offering me benefits or a living wage or even a chance of becoming full-time faculty, so...

What follows is part of an email I sent to my students last week:

As most of you are aware, I have a few problems with the way the First Year Writing program was set up. Overall, I would have preferred to give you more freedom in selecting writing topics. I would have liked to let you do some creative or personal writing as well. I would have preferred to leave the research/citation aspect of the class up to someone who's an expert in that area, as I think it distracted me from just getting everyone to write.

I sincerely hope that this does not turn you off to the idea of writing. I hope that you will all go on to take literature classes, poetry classes, and creative writing classes. I hope you will all discover (whether by reading or by writing) that words really do have power in this world. They can inspire you, make you feel connected to others, and set you free.


In that second paragraph lies my regret. Because I actually think I'm a pretty decent writing teacher. But I was given three freshman classes with fifteen students apiece, and two fifty-minute periods per week in which to teach them to write. Oh and, I wasn't supposed to supply the "content." The "content" was to come from their first-year seminar instructors.

Now, this school is not Harvard or Yale. There are some pretty serious academic "issues" at this school. There are ESL students, and students with learning disabilities, and students who are only there because their parents told them they have to go to college.

There were students (lots of 'em) who looked at me blankly when I asked them what they liked to read. There were students who could not or would not put away their handheld electronic devices even on threat of expulsion. There were chronic cut-and-paste plagiarizers who couldn't even be bothered to make the fonts match.

But I still think I could have taught them to write.

I wanted them to write about things they cared about; about things that excited them or moved them or scared them. I wanted them to feel free to write anything at all without being judged. I could have corrected their grammar, spelling and punctuation just as well in a personal essay as in a research paper... and I have no doubt in my mind that I would have read some amazing and revelatory things while I was at it.



16 comments:

Lindy said...

",,,who couldn't even be bothered to make the fonts match."

Doesn't that drive you nuts.

This week I've had several students offer very sincere-sounding apologies for their plagiarism. Not sure how sincere they actually are, but I'll take what I can get.

You may have inspired more students than you know.

renzmqt said...

Sweetheart, I hear every word you are saying, but that would be a creative writing class. Alas, even at Northwestern, I was required to take two Freshman seminars that were primarily to get us into the habit of writing college level research papers.

When I did home health there were those patients who had lovely sweet little homes, pressed cookies and coffee on you, it was as much a visit as a nursing encounter. Then there were the homes that were knee deep in filth, homes that reeked of dog urine, homes where the patient and/or family seemed genuinely hostile to your presence...

As much as I miss the former, I am so relieved not to have to do the latter...

I know from conversations that there were some genuine diamonds in the rough...but there also had to be some pigs (see below)...

In the end with those other students, I imagine it was like trying to teach pigs to fly, in the end it's impossible and it annoys the pig.

::hugs:: I think you made the right decision.

PS - I came over here via FB, so don't discount plugging your blog over there.

PJ DeGenaro said...

Our plagiarizers get kicked out. Well, firs they get a warning, then they get kicked out.

Thanks. I think I connected with three or four students somehow. :)

PJ DeGenaro said...

Renz, I hear you, but I don't think that's the right way to go about it.

I had kids who were barely literate mixed in with kids (a very few) who really didn't even need the class. The kids who were already decent writers could have just been placed in a "research" class. Whereas the kids who couldn't even write a complete sentence would have benefited from just doing LOTS and LOTS of writing -- about anything at all. (Or else they shouldn't have been in college just yet.)

Lisa said...

I completely sympathize and agree with just about everything you said. In fact, I've just about decided that I won't teach the intro comp class at the community college anymore. I'm leaning toward just teaching the feature writing course for the journalism program and, oddly, the remedial composition class.

I wonder if you would have preferred a remedial class too. The students are all fairly rough at the beginning. I take them from a hybrid personal/interpretive essay to increasingly more "academic" writing and they do improve with lots of in-class writing, which I can do because it's nearly a 2-hour class.

By contrast the non-remedial class sounds a lot like your class in organization and I have to follow the playbook. Maybe there is just something essentially "off" about the way colleges are doing basic intro to college writing classes. I suspect there's some need for reform.

The up side is you tried and now you know and you don't have to wonder. Besides, you are a rockin-good fiction writer and the world needs you doing that!

Dennis said...

"...who couldn't even be bothered to make the fonts match."

It is amazing how often they don't even bother, eh?

Paul said...

While I have never taught writing I do remember reading papers for a professor in seminary and this brings back memories. I sympathize with everything you said but want to focus not on teaching writing but on your feelings as you approached the college gates. That is a Really Big Thing and I am glad you paid attention to it. I believe one of life's great tasks, sadly, is learning to recognize and withdraw from that which is toxic for us - jobs, relationships, environments, whatever.

Bless you for doing it. Bless you for choosing not to in the upcoming year. And best wishes for whatever lies ahead.

PJ DeGenaro said...

Lisa, thanks! Yes, I think I would have just preferred not to teach research, databases, MLA formatting and whatnot. I mean, most of the time I was learning this stuff myself the night before class. Planning was hell. The whole thing was exhausting. I might have enjoyed a remedial class, simply because we could have focused on writing good sentences and paragraphs.

Dennis: I know, right?

Paul, thank you for noticing the Really Big Thing. I'm not the kind of person who generally has Job Dread, so this was awful! I thought I'd better take it seriously.

Ann said...

Prayers surrounding you -- may work that gives you hope and joy appear for you.

Jim said...

Sounds like you're at peace... almost?... with your decision, and it sounds like the right one. So that's one closed door. There's an open one somewhere around here, right?

PJ DeGenaro said...

Thanks Ann and Jim!

Well this just shows to go ya -- you have to link your blog to Facebook to get readers nowadays. ;)

johnieb said...

And you started blogging again when?
:-(

I think you were right to ditch this gig; I found enough grief in adjuncting to recognize another case. It's hell when you really love teaching.












9

eileen said...

(((((PJ))))))

Adjuncting is rough. 'Nuff said.

Grandmère Mimi said...

PJ, I loved your email to your students.

FWIW, I hated doing research papers, hated them, and I'm sure I would have hated teaching them.

What Paul said about how you felt driving through the gates. A warning, most certainly.

And I'm quite sure that you are/were a good writing teacher.

Jan said...

This is wonderful. I am wondering if this is where to find you now; I can't find your old blogs. Glad you're still writing.

PJ DeGenaro said...

Hi Jan, yep, this is where I am! Also on Facebook, like the rest of creation. :/